Zamira Solari
A wooden bench beside a quiet green neighborhood ballfield, framed by oaks and muted autumn foliage in Marin County.

Fairfax's School Street Plaza, From Hot Tubs and Softball to 243 Apartments

November 19, 2026

The building at the corner of School Street and Broadway is still standing. The Town of Fairfax reported on November 10 that demolition at 95 Broadway is underway. The crew started by removing pressure-treated materials, and the Town said work would begin with the buildings at the back of the property. The corner building that most people know from Broadway is scheduled to come down last. The Town said it will stay up until the contractor's shoring and sidewalk safety plan has been reviewed and approved.

Seen from the street, the plaza looked like one more low commercial block. The 1.92 acres behind that corner hold a lot of Fairfax history, and a 243-apartment building is planned to replace them.

Former school buildings, then live-work studios

The Town's housing inventory describes the site as 1.92 acres with a large terraced section, a big surface parking lot and several single-story buildings. It says those buildings were once school buildings and were later used as live-work spaces. The name on the street sign, School Street, matches.

The neighbors are familiar ones. The project narrative lists Fairfax Creek, Fairfax Lumber and Hardware and a baseball field along the property's edges, with other commercial uses around them. The Town's inventory names that field as Contratti Ball Field. It also notes that Fairfax Market, downtown shops and restaurants, parks and transit are all within walking distance of the plaza.

Frogs, up the hill from the ballfield

For many people around Marin, the plaza meant Frogs Hot Tubs. In its 2023 Best Of issue, the Pacific Sun listed Frogs at 10 School Street Plaza, Suite B. The paper described a 1970s-style retreat with a community hot tub, a cold-plunge pool, a clothing-optional sundeck, two private outdoor tubs and saunas running above 180 degrees. It said Frogs had been open for 32 years and kept hours from noon to 10:30 p.m., seven days a week.

When the San Francisco Chronicle wrote about the site in July 2025, it described the rambling wooden complex as boarded up. According to the paper, the property also once held yoga studios, and rock bands practiced in some of its rooms.

The Chronicle placed the tubs in a woodsy area next to Contratti Park, home field of West Marin Little League. The same story says the Grateful Dead played softball against Jefferson Airplane on that field in the mid-1960s. It also called Fairfax the town considered the birthplace of mountain biking, with four bike stores and a bicycle museum.

The plaza had other tenants too. According to a Town staff report prepared for an August 6, 2025 council meeting, the property owners told staff that Marin Alliance for Medical Marijuana had agreed to leave its plaza location by July 31, 2025.

The building planned for the lot

The owner and applicant on the project drawings is Mill Creek Residential Trust. The project calls for 243 apartments: 202 at market rate and 41 affordable. The November 2025 drawings show a six-story mixed-use building with commercial space on the ground floor, a parking garage about two and a half stories tall, and common courtyards totaling 5,930 square feet.

The design grew after the first filing. The Town's May 2025 notice of the full application described 5,750 square feet of commercial space, two parking levels and four residential stories.

These are the dates from the Town and the Marin Independent Journal:

Date What happened
May 8, 2025 Full application submitted to the Town
November 22, 2025 Town approval letter issued
November 25, 2025 Marin IJ reports the conditional approval
December 14, 2025 Marin IJ reports appeals filed by both the developer and opponents
January 23, 2026 Marin IJ reports one appeal rejected and the other withdrawn
October 30, 2026 Town posts notice that the demolition permit was issued
November 2, 2026 Marin IJ reports the demolition permit
November 10, 2026 Town reports demolition underway

The Independent Journal covered each step along the way, from the conditional approval to the competing appeals and how they were resolved. In its October 30 notice, the Town said it had not yet received any permit applications for the new building.

Neighbors brought the demolition to the Town Council quickly. At the November 5 meeting, Vice Mayor Egger asked to add an emergency agenda item to review the permit. According to the Citizen Portal summary of that meeting, she said the permit was issued after the agenda went out and that nearby residents and a Little League hadn't known demolition was about to start. Residents who spoke raised dust, possible asbestos and how neighbors were notified. The council did not add the item for action that night.

Getting around the site this winter

When crews haul debris out, the trucks will follow a set route through town. The hauling plan sends them out at School Street and Broadway, west on Broadway, then right on Azalea Avenue. From there they turn east on Sir Francis Drake Boulevard and take US-101 south to the Marin Resource Recovery Center at 565 Jacoby Street in San Rafael. That puts the trucks on Azalea Avenue and on Broadway west of the site.

The Town has asked people on foot to take care around the site and follow posted signs and detours. If you walk along School Street to Contratti Ball Field, or along Broadway past Fairfax Lumber and Hardware, you'll go right past the work.

The Town posts updates on its 95 Broadway project page. Questions about the demolition go to Building Official Mark Lockaby at [email protected] or 415-458-2370. To report activity on the site after hours, call police dispatch at 415-453-5530.

For more on Fairfax, see our Fairfax neighborhood guide and our recent look at the new bridges in Cascade Canyon.

If you live near Broadway, Azalea Avenue or Merwin Drive and want to talk through what a 243-unit building next to Contratti Park could mean for your street, Zamira Knows Marin is happy to sit down with you and look at it block by block.

Zamira Solari

Zamira's perfected the fine execution of a successful and seamless real estate deal while exceeding client expectations with superior concierge service, savvy negotiations, a brilliant marketing plan and proven track record that always lands her in the top echelon of Marin County Real Estate Agents. Zamira brings an exorbitant amount of energy and enthusiasm to work every single day. With the highest level of integrity and impeccable reputation, her clients are always confident she is the most passionate and determined advocate to get them the results they expect and desire. Contact Zamira today to discuss your real estate goals. She's ready for you!